Non-example of a monoid: 〈
N
+
,
+
〉
There is no right unit for the addition on the positive natural numbers.
Lemma
no_rht_unit_Npos
:
forall
y
: N
+
, ~
is_rht_unit
(
S
:=Npos)
Npos_plus
y
.
Therefore the set of positive natural numbers doesn't form a group with addition.
Lemma
no_monoid_Npos
:
forall
y
: N
+
, ~
is_CMonoid
Npos_as_CSemiGroup
y
.